112 Comments

And what else could they be doing with that $20 million? Feed children? House the homeless? Provide health care?

Expand full comment

$20M? What could $1B do? From the essay: A three year, one BILLION dollar ad campaign.

We’re just seeing the beginning.

Expand full comment

PAY TAXES! They are a business!

Expand full comment

Does anyone wonder; how much they fear us? We are the stones under their shoes that causes them to stumble. We are the upholders of the belief that people deserve good lives, and we work within the law to try and make it happen... No one group in the U.S. has made the lives of black and brown people and Natives better, but we try... and we know who they are who want to make all of our lives miserable so they can make ever more money. There was a bumper sticker in the 70's or 80's; He who dies with the most toys wins. It boggles my mind that this is their ambition, oh well that and enslaving the rest of us!

Expand full comment

Is it that, as Warren Buffett said, “after a certain, relatively small amount of money is attained, it all becomes a game…”!(Paraphrasing), or more that their being able to continue the game, depends on our not knowing what is happening to us…? Both I would guess…. And the conditioning that prevents us from realizing, begins very young, religion being one of the more effective tools, the quality and design of our compulsory education system, another… built in exhaustion/sleep deprivation connected with “working” long hours, when shorter hours render almost the same in production… food that fails to actually nourish…. Religious concepts like devils and demons and everlasting hell, introduced to the young at a trusting, easily impressionable age… Seems evermore like deliberate “brainwashing “…

Expand full comment

I know these people. I was raised in a church that did things like use kids to lure people into the park for a free concert. There'd be a half hour of a group singing pop music, then the audience would be clobbered with a fundamentalist sermon, ending with an alter call. We'd be turned loose in shopping malls, beaches and neighborhoods to hand out pamphlets and give witness. Even as a child, I was so conflicted and humiliated. On some level, I think I understood that it was wrong to bend people to my church's will. It all makes me cringe to think back on it. This is powerful stuff! Deep pockets out bid the will of the people, once again.

Expand full comment

At least, you survived with the coherence to realize what happened, and the benevolence to use your experience to create awareness…

Expand full comment

I've been seeing these ads for some time on Hulu, which I use for live TV. I admit they are warm and convincing. Having said that I had a sinking feeling and wondered what or who was behind it. I've learned to keep a skeptical eye on these things. Thank you, Jay, for researching and revealing the truth behind this.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I felt the same when I first saw the ads last year. Really made me wonder how they could afford these big ads and figured there must be some big conservative Christian groups backing them.

Expand full comment

How could anyone think that "Jesus loved the people we hate” is a good tagline? People we HATE? I thought one of the tenets of Christianity was to "love thy neighbor." This is sheer craziness. I have never been happier to be an atheist!

Expand full comment

It sure rings hollow to me

Expand full comment

Thank you Nancy and note the script "people WE [emphasis added] hate". That's a very clumsy effort to identify with Ad readers or should I say the "targeted market"?

Expand full comment

So the Jesus of the Bible served and preached the serving of the underserved, the forgotten, the "unclean". Even in the times this was written, this was a radical concept. The point is here is that the Jesus of the Bible lives the person you were cursing at in traffic, the person you disparaged on social media (or who disaraged you). The point here is, if you hate someone, Jesus doesn't just disagree with you, he does the opposite, he loves them. It's an ironic point when you look at the people funding it.

Expand full comment

Seriously, that jumped out at me as well

Expand full comment

The real Jesus wept and will continue weeping. This is actually pretty scary since so many people will not make the needed connections.

Expand full comment

So, the "Christians" spent $20 million on an ad rather than maybe giving that money to the poor, or possibly sending it to Turkey and Syria. Ridiculous waste of money.

Expand full comment

Thank you-thank you-thank you! The Jesus ads during the Super Bowl prompted me to ask the same questions you asked—and answered! I’m one of those people who reads the tiny print at the bottom of political ads, only to find they are funded by some anonymous “Foundation” or “Alliance.” I’m never able to find out who’s behind these organizations, and it drive me nuts! I think of the tens of thousands—literally millions, if you add them all up—of dollars spent on these ads and the good that money could do for some legitimate non-profits. It’s obscene. As for the messaging? Troubling to put it mildly. FYI, I signed up for your newsletters a while back, figuring I’d take a free trial for a while and see how things go. Today, I decided I’ll become a paid subscriber.

Expand full comment

Thank you for subscribing! Times are a bit tight, with Elon Musk having eviscerated our business, but we are managing to get by. The support of readers here is enormously helpful through this tough time.

Expand full comment

How has Elon Musk been able to eviscerate your newsletter business?

Expand full comment

He didn’t destroy the newsletter business, but he took the legs out from our video content business on Twitter. We used to generate around half of our income from pre-roll ads on our video pieces that we created on Twitter for our audiences there. But Elon let back on the platform all these alt-right, neo-Nazi types, and the advertisers fled. Business fell by 80% along with revenues. I had to lay off nearly all our video department and took a 66% pay cut just so we could stay afloat longer while we figured out a way through. It’s been so stressful, all because of one man-baby billionaire.

Expand full comment

Oh no! Thank you for sharing the details and this is terrible! Is there an opportunity to replicate your business model on YouTube?

Expand full comment

We don’t have much of an audience developed there so it would take years to achieve. On Twitter we had over 17 million followers in the accounts we managed. We lost one of our major clients after Elon destroyed the core advertising base, and now we are trying to rebuild with new partners. It’s not easy…

Expand full comment

Super Bowl ads cost about $7M for 30 seconds. More/less depending on exactly when during the show.

Expand full comment

Trying to sell Jesus while telling us they hate people, is quite an interesting strategy.

Expand full comment

Their usual bizarre pretzel illogic. #KochNetwork

Expand full comment

Exactly! I don't understand that train of thought - at all.

Expand full comment

Thanks for writing about this. I was in bed by 930 and missed most of the game so I didn't see the commercials.

I've been seeing the He Gets Us billboards and ads a lot over the last few years. As a lapsed catholic I have no intention to ever join any church again. But I'm glad to know what they stand for and who backs them. All you had to say was Hobby Lobby. They have been on my boycott list since the contraception injustice.

Expand full comment

Exactly right! One. Big. Deception. If you're not already clued into the word "Dominionism", it's a good one to tune in to. Jenny Cohn writes a lot about it on Twitter and in the Bucks County Beacon. It's scary beyond-evangelicalism stuff.

https://buckscountybeacon.com/2022/10/dominionism-is-on-the-ballot-in-november-but-most-voters-have-never-heard-of-it/

Expand full comment

Woah. I not know about this group. The name “dominion” sounds right out of Star Trek as a morality play (because it is).

Expand full comment

Scott & John thank you for the important Link & 'dominionism's push for a "WILD" meeting on J6 between "10 am & 6 pm" at the Capitol. Jesus for sedition?

Expand full comment

Interesting (and scary) article.

Expand full comment

Also, @brucewilson @Tentoads4truth @dailykos @anelsona #ShadowNetwork @NancyMacLean5 #DemocracyInChains @JaneMayerNYer #DarkMoney @truthout @pressprogress etc.

Expand full comment

I hope my missing the horses didn’t come across as trite - in fact I am thinking of telling the other Super Bowl advertisers that I will personally turn away from their products. They are running in a crowd with hateful frightening people intent on destroying our country.

Jays post here is an excellent based for frank talks with my children and grandchildren about why it is important to follow the golden rule - find out who owns the gold because they seek to rule.

I am afraid for our future ...

Expand full comment

This whole thing disgusts me. If they really wanted to follow Jesus' message, imagine how many people they could feed with those millions! Or any number of charitable acts this money could fund!

Expand full comment

Thank you. Clear and intelligent, as usual. Always follow the money.

Expand full comment

Wouldn't it be a better if all this money was spent helping those in need??

Expand full comment

The money IS helping those in need ...THEMSELVES.

Expand full comment

Last night, during the Super Bowl, was the first time I saw this ad, and I immediately turned to the small group I was watching with and said: "What was that? What is it doing on FOX? And what exactly is it advertising? We were all scratching our heads and joked: Must be an ad about CHEESES! We sure like CHEESES!

Seriously, do they not have any shame!? Now they are using the teachings of Jesus to manipulate and gaslight!?! That is what I suspected was happening, especially as it aired on FOX.

Thank you, Jay, for confirming my suspicions!

Expand full comment

At least CHEESES can be holy.

Expand full comment

JFC...

Expand full comment