23 Comments

It bugs me that the ‘red waves’ in Florida and Ohio don’t have an asterisk and a reminder that they were stolen. But the illegally gerrymandered maps can be fixed for 2024, right?

Expand full comment

What nonsense. Rs got more votes than Ds in Florida. You are living in a partisan fantasy world, Maggie.

Expand full comment

The senate race was won roughly 52% - 48%. The house seats were won 17 - 7. That's gerrymandering at its finest.

Expand full comment

Maggie, but what was the aggregate vote total for Republicans and Democrats in the House races?

Expand full comment

I don’t know, do you?

Expand full comment

Maybe, but Ohio GOP just took more Supreme Court Seats so now they might look the other way in 2024's map redraw. (if they even complete one)

Expand full comment

I was redistricted this year. We went from being included in the downtown very blue leaning area to the rural red. I told my husband we were a casualty of gerrymandering. Its yet unseen how it's been impacted. We were able to unseat Jamie Herera Butler and will now have a Democrat in that seat.

Expand full comment

This is so frustrating. They cheat while screaming the Democrats are cheating, disenfranchising voters and not making sure all are represented needs to stop how do we make that happen. This has gone on far to long!

Expand full comment

So how many candidates ran on unfair gerrymandering in their state? Since gerrymandering is harmful as institutionalized, it will continue to hurt us. Gerrymandering is a real thief of democracy.

Expand full comment

Gerrymandering rigs elections. Americans would not stand for a touchdown counting for 9 points and only 6 points for the other team. But that 40% percentage of state-wide vote totals reflected in representation of some legislatures.

Expand full comment

Is it 2103 Shelby County ruling or 2013? I think that might be a typo.

Expand full comment

I think our best chance of flipping flippable seats in 2024 is going to come from registering more Gen Z voters. They turned out in good numbers, compared to youth turnout in prior elections, but there is a lot more room for growth there. We need to register young people on college campuses, and pre-register 16 and 17 year olds who will vote in 2024. And we've got to start now, not 90 days before the next election.

Expand full comment

What are the best words to use when 40% of a state wide vote all but guarantees ‘it’ gets to elect the majority of the state legislature —like in Wisconsin and other states. Gerrymandering and disenfranchisement of voters are one and the same.

Expand full comment

Come on, Jay. “Just how bad gerrymandering hurt us?” It’s “badly.” Other than that, keep up the good work.

Expand full comment

Excellent, thorough and historical analysis.

Expand full comment
founding

Lawmakers should not be able to make laws that benefit them in the electoral process.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the great explanation.

Expand full comment

I'm ll check and get back. My point is, the Senate percentage isn't necessarily indicative of the House races' aggregate percentage.

Expand full comment

Can Persident Biden expand the SCOTUS by executive order ?

Expand full comment

On CNN's election data site they show the total national vote for House members, broken down by GOP and Dem:

* Republicans 51.3% 52,197,405 (4,671,393 ahead)

* Democrats 46.8% 47,526,012

* Est. vote in: 91% Updated 2:42 p.m. ET, Nov. 14

This seems incongruous with my understanding the both sides do Gerrymandering, the GOP does more. I have not seen any election analysts address these numbers or whether they look accurate. Anyone have any insight or seen or heard any addressing of this?

Expand full comment

Did not Republican candidates in total receive millions more votes than Democrats? I think so. Also, the overspending by the Democrat- controlled government needs to be stopped ..our interest on our national debt now exceeds our annual GNP.

Expand full comment

1. You "think" Republicans received millions more votes than Dems? Please support this with solid data - once all the votes have been counted

2. Oh, and since in a presidential election an antiquated game called the electoral college rules, it hardly matters who or which party cast more votes, does it? If it had, Hillary would have easily beaten *trump.

Expand full comment